Mysterypage

How we label evidence

We label each claim, not the case as a whole, and never the people in it.

Most mysteries mix solid records with rumor. A single verdict for a whole case hides that, so every Mysterypage entry opens with a table that splits the case into individual claims. Each row carries three labels and at least one source.

The two axes

Event asks whether the thing happened as described. Explanation asks whether there is an agreed cause. A claim can be well documented and still unexplained, or poorly documented and easily explained, so the two are kept apart.

Event

Did it happen as described?

Documented
Records from the time (official documents, news of the time, instrument data) show it occurred.
Disputed
Credible sources conflict on whether it occurred as described.
Unverified
It rests on testimony or claims without independent records.

Explanation

Is there an agreed cause?

Accepted
An ordinary cause is supported by documented evidence and is the mainstream finding.
Competing
Two or more sourced explanations, with no consensus.
Unknown
No explanation is supported by evidence yet. We always say what would settle it.

Science scale

For physics and astronomy concepts.

Established
In peer-reviewed consensus, and observed or tested.
Theoretical
Consistent with accepted physics in the literature, but unobserved.
Speculative
Goes beyond current theory, or is a thought experiment.

The science scale

Physics and astronomy concepts, such as a Dyson sphere, are not events, so the question "did it happen?" doesn't fit them. Those claims are rated on the science scale instead: Established, Theoretical or Speculative. Every claim table has a Science column. It reads n/a for claims that aren't about a science concept, and entries in the Speculative science collection must fill it on every row.

When a label reads n/a

An Explanation of n/a means no cause is being weighed on that row. That happens in two kinds of row. Some state a rival theory itself, for example "a later writer proposed that…": whether the proposal was made can be Documented, and the theory is weighed in the Competing explanations section instead. Others state a plain record fact, such as when a building was finished or what a register says, where there is nothing to explain. In the Science column, n/a means the row isn't about a science concept.

How much evidence each label needs

"Unknown" is never a shrug

Every entry has a What would settle it section naming the record, test or find that would move a label. Each competing explanation gets its strongest sourced case for and against, with no ridicule either way.

Labels change when evidence changes

Every entry ends with a dated evidence log. When a new source appears or a label moves, the change is recorded there with its date, and the entry's "Last reviewed" date and version are updated.

How we write

Source tiers, corrections and takedowns